Robot Surgeries Lead to Multiple Lawsuits

Robot Surgeries Lead to Multiple Lawsuits

By:
Stephen M. Smith
|
Last Updated:
November 26, 2019
Best Law Firm logo
Robot Arms Performing High-Precision Nanosurgery.

Robot surgeries have changed the face of medicine, allowing patients to undergo quicker and less invasive operations.

However, worrying questions remain about these surgeries after some patients alleged they sustained serious injuries like burns. Robotic surgeries are even linked to deaths.

Many of the patients brought lawsuits over the da Vinci surgical robot, a device approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration in 2000.

At the Smith Law Center, our attorneys have years of experience in complicated product liability cases as well as hospital negligence lawsuits.

What is the Da Vinci Robot?

The da Vinci robot offers the promise of minimally invasive surgery. This means patients recover more quickly from operations. The robots allow surgeons to perform operations by making a few small incisions in the patient. Silicon Valley’s Intuitive Surgical manufactures the da Vinci robot.

Surgeons operate the system via foot pedals, joysticks, and a 3-D viewer.  The da Vinci robot has a monitor that lets surgeons see inside patients, and a steady robotic arm allowing for more precision. Surgeries using the da Vinci robot are associated with faster recovery times for the patient.

What are the Risks of the Da Vinci Robot?

While the da Vinci robot appears to deliver minimally invasive surgery, some people who underwent operations claimed it left them injured.

NBC News highlighted the case of Laurie Featherstone from Iowa in 2018. Featherstone said before she was due to have a hysterectomy in March 2015 her doctor asked her if she would consider having a robot conduct the procedure.

Featherstone said she wanted the operation because of fibroids in her uterus. Complications emerged a few weeks after the procedure involving the Da Vinci robot.

The woman experienced excess fluids in her kidneys. She suffered an ailment called hydronephrosis. One of her ureters was damaged. The doctors said the robotic hysterectomy caused the injury.

The procedure burned Featherstone’s ureter and damaged her colon. Doctors said she required a permanent colostomy.

Featherstone filed a lawsuit but withdrew it when she ran up against her state’s Statute of Limitations.

This was not an isolated incident. NBC analyzed adverse effects associated with robotic surgery.  A U.S. Food and Drug Administration study revealed robotic surgeries caused 20,000 adverse events. Most of them were filed by Intuitive Surgical, the maker of the da Vinci robot.

Despite the findings, more and more women use the Da Vinci robot for hysterectomies and more hospitals are adopting robotic technologies.

As well as hysterectomies, surgeons use robotic systems to perform other surgeries including urology procedures, heart surgeries, and urology procedures.

NBC News reported an increase in the number of surgeries using da Vinci robots by 52 percent since 2013. Surgeries rose to nearly 700,000 procedures in 2017.

Over 2,000 adverse events involved injuries and 274 were categorized as deaths, the report revealed.

What Are the Most Common Injuries Associated with the Da Vinci Robot?

Lawsuits brought against Intuitive Surgical claim the following injuries and complications:

  • Burns to organs;
  • Punctures or cut ureters;
  • Perforations or tears to organs;
  • Injuries to the bowel or the bladder.

Surgeon inexperience appears to be another factor in da Vinci robot injuries.  Using the new robotic system requires a surgeon to become comfortable with new controls. Some lawsuits claimed surgeons received insufficient training for the robotic systems.

Device malfunction has also been cited in lawsuits.  Some injuries were linked to the da Vinci EndoWrist Monopolar Curved Scissors. Invisible cracks in the device caused internal burns to the patient. This accessory was later withdrawn from the market.

Lawsuits against Intuitive claim that the da Vinci robot suffered from design defects. Other lawsuits alleged medical malpractice. While some injures are linked to alleged da Vinci design defects or manufacturing defects injuries may have been caused by doctors who failed to use the equipment properly or received inadequate training to use this complicated robot.

Contact a Virginia Injury Lawyer if You Were Injured by Robotic Surgery

Increasing numbers of hospitals in Virginia and elsewhere use robot surgery for procedures. However, the large number of reported injuries suggests a range of problems with the new technology. Robotic surgery is linked to hundreds of injuries and some deaths.

If you or a family member has been injured during robot surgery, please call our trial lawyers today at (757) 244-7000.

Lawyers at Smith Law Center

About Smith Law Center

Our lawyers are more than lawyers. They are people who understand your injuries and the law that surrounds your options when it comes to holding others accountable.
ABOUT US

What Our Clients Are Saying About Us

Tony Laizure, Principal Laizure Law
Google logo

I have had the immense pleasure to work with Stephen M. Smith many times over the years, and every case ends in success for the client. He is so passionate about his clients and cares deeply about them.

Anonymous (Former Client)
Google logo

They treat you with respect & compassion every step of the way…

Jonathan Wren
Google logo

Great firm. Stephen, David, and their team did a wonderful job representing a brain-injured client I referred to them for hard-fought case against a trucking company in federal court.

Shannon Laymon-Pecoraro
Google logo

I have the pleasure of working with the team at the Smith Law Center regularly. They are well rounded, and their commitment to their clients is top notch.

Donna
Google logo

… your firm is personally responsible for taking what was a horrible tragedy and transforming it into a legacy…

Joe
Google logo

… [Mr. Smith's] style of representation was impeccable, classy, and he cleverly executed every facet of the case …

Nancy
Google logo

… I really can’t thank you enough for securing the damages to which I was entitled …

Marybeth
Google logo

… I am beyond grateful for their caring manner, their legal prowess, and their attention to detail …

Tom
Google logo

Although this card is rather small, the “Thank You” isn’t small at all … You will never know what this money has meant to us. It does not remove the affects of the stroke, but makes things somewhat better …

Tammy & John
Google logo

… For such a large firm, we received very personal care. We will always recommend you highly! …

Angelicia S
Google logo

I had the pleasure of working with Attorney Gill. He was very professional and made the process worth the while. This law firm cares about their clients and it shows. Thank you all for going over and beyond.

Erin L
Google logo

I was very happy with the Smith Law Center. They are professional, attentive and will truly fight for you. The entire office is very nice and communicates throughout the whole process. Mr. Gill is fantastic as well as the paralegals and the other administration team.

Mike S
Google logo

David Holt did an excellent job dealing with a largely uncooperative insurance adjuster. He explored all avenues of recovery, their fees were fair and, once settled, payment was prompt. Five stars all the way.

Christin S
Google logo

Working with David and Lisa was a wonderful experience. I was overwhelmed by their kindness and efficiency.

Kevin Mottley
Google logo

I have had the pleasure of working alongside Stephen Smith, David Holt, and Stewart Gill for several years now, representing traumatic brain injury survivors in fights against insurance companies. These guys are a pleasure to work with and are true trial lawyers who fight for their clients day in and day out in court.

Andy H
Google logo

The attorneys and staff at Smith Law Center are great to work with. They care not only about a successful recovery, but ensuring their clients know what options are available for protecting the recovery long-term.

Shaminece H.
Google logo

The team and my attorney were so friendly. They were always available to help me or answer my questions, and the process wasn’t long at all. I’m so grateful for the services they gave me and for treating me like family.

Shannon L
Google logo

... I have the pleasure of working with the team at the Smith Law Center regularly ... They are well rounded, and their commitment to their clients is top notch.

Andy H
Google logo

... The attorneys and staff are great to work with ... They care not only about a successful recovery, but ensuring their clients know what options are available for protecting the recovery long-term.

Jonathan B
Google logo

... Mr. Smith helped us get a settlement fast, and things are much better now ...Without Stephen’s help I’d probably be dead and penniless. I am a brain injury survivor. On the 4th of July weekend (in 2004), my life was turned inside out when I was hit on my motorcycle. My brother-in-law was searching for brain injury specialists and happened to find Mr. Smith. And he was a lawyer too! Mr. Smith helped us get a settlement fast, and things are much better now.